{"id":392156,"access":"public","admin_noindex":false,"asset_url":"https://s3.documentcloud.org/","canonical_url":"https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/392156-scotus-health-care-ruling/","created_at":"2012-06-28T14:36:53.401192Z","data":{},"description":"The U.S. Supreme Court on Thursday upheld the Affordable Care Act. Use this interactive to navigate to portions of the ruling. NPR reporters will update this feature throughout the day. ","edit_access":false,"file_hash":"","noindex":false,"language":"eng","organization":{"id":11,"avatar_url":"https://cdn.muckrock.com/media/org_avatars/ms3D5ipo_400x400.jpg","individual":false,"name":"NPR","slug":"npr","uuid":"7b57577f-cb5d-43ec-b077-15205338b5cb"},"original_extension":"pdf","page_count":193,"page_spec":"612.0x792.0:0-192","projects":[{"id":6556,"created_at":"2020-10-14T20:17:14.890238Z","description":"","edit_access":false,"add_remove_access":false,"private":false,"slug":"overview-project","title":"Overview Project","updated_at":"2020-10-14T20:17:14.892094Z","user":2254,"pinned":false}],"publish_at":null,"published_url":"","related_article":"http://www.npr.org/blogs/thetwo-way/2012/06/28/155901105/live-blog-the-health-care-ruling","revision_control":false,"slug":"scotus-health-care-ruling","source":"U.S. Supreme Court","status":"success","title":"SCOTUS Health Care Ruling","updated_at":"2020-11-10T17:17:53.169551Z","user":{"id":2254,"avatar_url":"","name":"Matt Stiles","organization":16323,"organizations":[16323],"admin_organizations":[16323],"username":"MattStiles","uuid":"bfb0dffb-ae2e-463b-9ef3-16622222a61a","verified_journalist":true},"sections":[{"id":12261,"page_number":0,"title":"Syllabus"},{"id":12266,"page_number":6,"title":"Roberts Opinion"},{"id":12267,"page_number":65,"title":"Ginsburg Opinion"},{"id":12268,"page_number":126,"title":"Scalia, Kennedy, Thomas, Alito Dissent"},{"id":12269,"page_number":191,"title":"Thomas Dissent"}],"notes":[{"id":61902,"user":{"id":2254,"avatar_url":"","name":"Matt Stiles","organization":16323,"organizations":[16323],"admin_organizations":[16323],"username":"MattStiles","uuid":"bfb0dffb-ae2e-463b-9ef3-16622222a61a","verified_journalist":true},"organization":11,"page_number":37,"access":"public","edit_access":false,"title":"Roberts: Hooper v. California","content":"The chief justice cites an 1890s insurance case: \"Every reasonable construction must be resorted to, in order to save a statute from unconstitutionality.\"","x1":0.17857142857142858,"x2":0.8571428571428571,"y1":0.5221428571428571,"y2":0.8190909090909091,"created_at":"2012-06-28T16:46:15.424456Z","updated_at":"2020-11-10T17:18:01.430878Z"},{"id":61909,"user":{"id":2254,"avatar_url":"","name":"Matt Stiles","organization":16323,"organizations":[16323],"admin_organizations":[16323],"username":"MattStiles","uuid":"bfb0dffb-ae2e-463b-9ef3-16622222a61a","verified_journalist":true},"organization":11,"page_number":38,"access":"public","edit_access":false,"title":"Roberts: Penalty Is, and Isn't, A Tax","content":"From SCOTUSblog's Lyle Denniston: \"Interesting, at least to scholars, that ... the mandate and its attached penalty are a tax for purposes of its constitutionality, but not for the Anti-Injunction Act. If it were a tax for AIA purposes, this case would not have been decided [regarding] the mandate.\" \n\nTejinder Singh explains at SCOTUSblog.","x1":0.17857142857142858,"x2":0.8814285714285715,"y1":0.5795454545454546,"y2":0.8577272727272728,"created_at":"2012-06-28T16:53:44.409614Z","updated_at":"2020-11-10T17:18:01.430664Z"},{"id":61808,"user":{"id":2254,"avatar_url":"","name":"Matt Stiles","organization":16323,"organizations":[16323],"admin_organizations":[16323],"username":"MattStiles","uuid":"bfb0dffb-ae2e-463b-9ef3-16622222a61a","verified_journalist":true},"organization":11,"page_number":44,"access":"public","edit_access":false,"title":"Roberts: Government's Taxing Power","content":"SCOTUSblog's Amy Howe calls this the \"money quote\" of the section dealing with the individual mandate.","x1":0.23,"x2":0.7842857142857143,"y1":0.5243506493506493,"y2":0.700974025974026,"created_at":"2012-06-28T15:13:55.015876Z","updated_at":"2020-11-10T17:18:01.428361Z"},{"id":61816,"user":{"id":2254,"avatar_url":"","name":"Matt Stiles","organization":16323,"organizations":[16323],"admin_organizations":[16323],"username":"MattStiles","uuid":"bfb0dffb-ae2e-463b-9ef3-16622222a61a","verified_journalist":true},"organization":11,"page_number":60,"access":"public","edit_access":false,"title":"Roberts: Congress Cannot Take States' Existing Medicare Funds","content":"SCOTUSblog's Lyle Denniston identifies this quote from Chief Justice John Roberts as the \"key comment on salvaging the Medicaid expansion.\"","x1":0.24571428571428572,"x2":0.78,"y1":0.6281168831168831,"y2":0.8135714285714286,"created_at":"2012-06-28T15:19:48.513801Z","updated_at":"2020-11-10T17:18:01.429930Z"},{"id":61805,"user":{"id":2254,"avatar_url":"","name":"Matt Stiles","organization":16323,"organizations":[16323],"admin_organizations":[16323],"username":"MattStiles","uuid":"bfb0dffb-ae2e-463b-9ef3-16622222a61a","verified_journalist":true},"organization":11,"page_number":64,"access":"public","edit_access":false,"title":"Roberts: Conclusion","content":"","x1":0.23714285714285716,"x2":0.7914285714285715,"y1":0.29474025974025975,"y2":0.4868181818181818,"created_at":"2012-06-28T15:11:40.260530Z","updated_at":"2020-11-10T17:18:01.428141Z"},{"id":61825,"user":{"id":2254,"avatar_url":"","name":"Matt Stiles","organization":16323,"organizations":[16323],"admin_organizations":[16323],"username":"MattStiles","uuid":"bfb0dffb-ae2e-463b-9ef3-16622222a61a","verified_journalist":true},"organization":11,"page_number":66,"access":"public","edit_access":false,"title":"Ginsburg: Roberts 'Rigid Reading' of the Commerce Clause","content":"","x1":0.20857142857142857,"x2":0.7885714285714286,"y1":0.3962987012987013,"y2":0.5155194805194805,"created_at":"2012-06-28T15:24:54.545241Z","updated_at":"2020-11-10T17:18:01.431538Z"},{"id":62030,"user":{"id":2254,"avatar_url":"","name":"Matt Stiles","organization":16323,"organizations":[16323],"admin_organizations":[16323],"username":"MattStiles","uuid":"bfb0dffb-ae2e-463b-9ef3-16622222a61a","verified_journalist":true},"organization":11,"page_number":76,"access":"public","edit_access":false,"title":"Ginsburg: 'Congress Followed Massachusetts' Lead'","content":"","x1":0.23,"x2":0.7842857142857143,"y1":0.2196753246753247,"y2":0.45590909090909093,"created_at":"2012-06-28T19:45:24.203772Z","updated_at":"2020-11-10T17:18:01.428796Z"},{"id":61826,"user":{"id":2254,"avatar_url":"","name":"Matt Stiles","organization":16323,"organizations":[16323],"admin_organizations":[16323],"username":"MattStiles","uuid":"bfb0dffb-ae2e-463b-9ef3-16622222a61a","verified_journalist":true},"organization":11,"page_number":125,"access":"public","edit_access":false,"title":"Ginsburg: Medicaid Expansion 'Within Congress' Spending Power","content":"","x1":0.21285714285714286,"x2":0.8028571428571428,"y1":0.5983116883116883,"y2":0.7705194805194805,"created_at":"2012-06-28T15:26:10.603692Z","updated_at":"2020-11-10T17:18:01.429670Z"},{"id":61876,"user":{"id":2254,"avatar_url":"","name":"Matt Stiles","organization":16323,"organizations":[16323],"admin_organizations":[16323],"username":"MattStiles","uuid":"bfb0dffb-ae2e-463b-9ef3-16622222a61a","verified_journalist":true},"organization":11,"page_number":127,"access":"public","edit_access":false,"title":"'Structural Limits Upon Federal Power'","content":"","x1":0.21,"x2":0.8071428571428572,"y1":0.49454545454545457,"y2":0.7241558441558441,"created_at":"2012-06-28T16:15:05.886556Z","updated_at":"2020-11-10T17:18:01.429231Z"},{"id":61820,"user":{"id":2254,"avatar_url":"","name":"Matt Stiles","organization":16323,"organizations":[16323],"admin_organizations":[16323],"username":"MattStiles","uuid":"bfb0dffb-ae2e-463b-9ef3-16622222a61a","verified_journalist":true},"organization":11,"page_number":128,"access":"public","edit_access":false,"title":"Act 'Exceeds Federal Power'","content":"","x1":0.20714285714285716,"x2":0.8342857142857143,"y1":0.6634415584415585,"y2":0.8555194805194806,"created_at":"2012-06-28T15:21:44.907936Z","updated_at":"2020-11-10T17:18:01.428581Z"},{"id":61843,"user":{"id":2254,"avatar_url":"","name":"Matt Stiles","organization":16323,"organizations":[16323],"admin_organizations":[16323],"username":"MattStiles","uuid":"bfb0dffb-ae2e-463b-9ef3-16622222a61a","verified_journalist":true},"organization":11,"page_number":128,"access":"public","edit_access":false,"title":"'Extend Federal Power To Virtually All Human Activity'","content":"","x1":0.24857142857142858,"x2":0.77,"y1":0.21415584415584416,"y2":0.31902597402597405,"created_at":"2012-06-28T15:49:07.947005Z","updated_at":"2020-11-10T17:18:01.430142Z"},{"id":61878,"user":{"id":2254,"avatar_url":"","name":"Matt Stiles","organization":16323,"organizations":[16323],"admin_organizations":[16323],"username":"MattStiles","uuid":"bfb0dffb-ae2e-463b-9ef3-16622222a61a","verified_journalist":true},"organization":11,"page_number":132,"access":"public","edit_access":false,"title":"Costs to the Insurance Industry","content":"","x1":0.2042857142857143,"x2":0.7885714285714286,"y1":0.31792207792207794,"y2":0.5155194805194805,"created_at":"2012-06-28T16:16:48.017470Z","updated_at":"2020-11-10T17:18:01.431322Z"},{"id":61842,"user":{"id":2254,"avatar_url":"","name":"Matt Stiles","organization":16323,"organizations":[16323],"admin_organizations":[16323],"username":"MattStiles","uuid":"bfb0dffb-ae2e-463b-9ef3-16622222a61a","verified_journalist":true},"organization":11,"page_number":143,"access":"public","edit_access":false,"title":"'Cannot Rewrite The Statute To Be What It Is Not'","content":"","x1":0.24285714285714285,"x2":0.77,"y1":0.22961038961038963,"y2":0.404025974025974,"created_at":"2012-06-28T15:47:21.400147Z","updated_at":"2020-11-10T17:18:01.429449Z"},{"id":61874,"user":{"id":2254,"avatar_url":"","name":"Matt Stiles","organization":16323,"organizations":[16323],"admin_organizations":[16323],"username":"MattStiles","uuid":"bfb0dffb-ae2e-463b-9ef3-16622222a61a","verified_journalist":true},"organization":11,"page_number":192,"access":"public","edit_access":false,"title":"Thomas: Regulating Economic Activity vs. Inactivity","content":"Thomas offered his own short dissent. ","x1":0.24857142857142858,"x2":0.7785714285714286,"y1":0.36318181818181816,"y2":0.44266233766233765,"created_at":"2012-06-28T16:12:18.913842Z","updated_at":"2020-11-10T17:18:01.430445Z"}]}